This policy helps homeowners, homebuyers, drivers and car owners, small businesses, and renters by stopping the predatory corporate pass-throughs that drive up insurance premiums, disrupt mortgage closings, fuel foreclosures, and raise monthly rents.
No. There are limited costs to states associated with enforcement, which should be offset by enforcement penalties.
This act shall be known as the Coverage Not Corporate Cash-grabs Act.
These model provisions prohibit home and auto insurers from passing unjustifiable corporate expenses onto policyholders.
1. (Preventing Unjustifiable Corporate Expenses): These model provisions prevent insurers from passing to policyholders the costs of expenses unrelated to risk and reasonable profit such as regulatory fines and penalties, court judgments and legal fees, lobbying and political contributions, excessive executive compensation, and advertising.
a. Sample language:
i. Prohibition on unjustifiable corporate expenses in base rate calculations.
1. No insurer transacting property, casualty, homeowners, renters, commercial, or private passenger automobile insurance in [STATE] shall pass through to policyholders or include in any base rate calculation the following unjustifiable corporate expenses adapted from Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2644.10:
a. Regulatory fines, civil penalties, or assessments levied against the insurer or an affiliate; adapted from Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2644.10(e)
b. Court judgments, settlements, punitive damages, or legal defense or adverse attorney fees in any action or proceeding where the insurer was found to have acted in bad faith, or in which the insured or beneficiary prevailed; adapted from Florida SB 1684 as introduced (2017)
c. Lobbying expenditures, political contributions, political action committee expenses, or costs incurred to influence state, federal, or local policies; adapted from Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2644.10(a)
d. Excessive executive compensation, salaries, stock options, and profit-sharing bonuses paid to corporate officers or executives that exceed reasonable industry benchmarks established by rule of the [Department of Insurance or relevant department] hereinafter “Department”;
e. Institutional advertising expenses aimed at promoting the corporate image of the insurer rather than obtaining business for a specific insurer or providing consumers with information pertinent to the decision whether to buy the insurer’s product; adapted from Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2644.10(f) and
f. All payments to affiliates, to the extent that such payments exceed the fair market rate or value of the goods or services in the open market. adapted from Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2644.10(g)
ii. Public reporting of removed unjustifiable corporate expenses. Every insurer submitting a rate application shall file an excluded expense statement report to the Department detailing all unjustifiable corporate expenses that were removed from the base rate calculation. All information on removed unjustifiable corporate expenses reported to the Department shall be classified as a public record and published on the Department’s publicly available website.adapted from Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2644.10
iii. Executive certification under penalty of perjury. The excluded expense statement and accompanying rate application shall be certified under oath and subject to the penalty of perjury by both the insurer’s chief financial officer and chief actuary, attesting that they have reviewed the filing and that no unjustifiable corporate expenses have been included in the base rate calculation.adapted from Fla. Stat. § 627.062(8)(a)
iv. Penalties
1. Any entity that uses any rate, rating plan, rating system, or base rate calculation in violation of this section shall be liable for a civil penalty of not more than $5,000 for each violation, or not more than $10,000 for each willful violation. For purposes of this section, each insurance policy issued or renewed using an unlawful rate shall constitute a separate violation.adapted from Cal. Ins. Code § 1858.07
2. Any entity that fails to comply with a final rate, audit, or restitution order of the Department under this Act shall be liable to the state for a civil penalty of not more than $50,000, or not more than $250,000 if the failure to comply was willful. adapted from Cal. Ins. Code § 1859.1
3. Notwithstanding the maximum penalty amounts set forth in this subsection, the aggregate civil penalty assessed for a violation of this Act shall include restitution for the full costs of auditing, investigating, and enforcing this Act.
v. Automatic Restitution and Interest Penalties. If the Department determines that an insurer has overcharged policyholders after the enactment of this Act due to the inclusion of any unjustifiable corporate expense in a rate calculation, the Department shall order the insurer to directly refund all affected policyholders the full amount of the overcharge, any applicable claim multipliers, and an automatic eight percent per annum simple interest penalty calculated on the overcharged amount from the date the excessive premium was collected until the date the refund is paid in full to the policyholder. adapted from WA SB 5331
vi. Mandatory policyholder notice at issuance and renewal. Every insurer issuing or renewing a homeowners, renters, property, or private passenger automobile insurance policy in [STATE] shall provide a conspicuous written notice in at least 12-point boldface type at the beginning of each billing and renewal statement, regardless of whether the statement is delivered in paper or electronic form. For policyholders who receive billing and renewal statements electronically, the notice shall appear prominently on the first screen or page of the electronic statement, or in the body of the email or electronic message transmitting the statement, before any attachment or link, and shall be displayed without requiring the policyholder to scroll, click, or take any other action to view it. The notice shall state the following exact text:
1. “NOTICE TO POLICYHOLDERS: Under a new policy enacted by the [STATE] Legislature to lower your insurance costs, your insurance company is prohibited by law from passing corporate expenses onto you — including political lobbying, excessive executive bonuses, institutional image advertising, inflated affiliate fees, and legal fines or penalties for bad-faith business practices. You can view your insurer’s excluded expense statement at [Department Website URL] or learn how to submit a complaint if you believe your insurer is in violation. Insurance companies in violation will be required to refund you any unlawful overcharges with eight percent interest.”
vii. The provisions of this Act are severable. If any provision of this Act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
viii. [STATE] has a compelling interest in protecting privacy and personal information of consumers. In administering this Act, state and local agencies, businesses, and any other entities, shall only request data necessary to administer this Act and retain it only as required to administer and achieve the purposes of the Act. Any personal information of consumers or their data collected or obtained in the course of administering this Act shall be shared only in a manner that has been deidentified and aggregated to the greatest extent allowable. A consumer’s personal information or data collected or obtained in the course of administering this Act shall not be otherwise disclosed without the informed consent of the individual, a warrant signed by a [STATE] judge or federal judge, lawful court order administered within [STATE] or a lawful federal court order, or subpoena administered within [STATE] or federal subpoena, or unless otherwise required by federal or state statute. Personal information or data may be considered deidentified if it cannot reasonably be used to infer information about, or otherwise be linked to, a particular individual or household. Nothing in this subsection shall be construed to limit or restrict the ability of the Attorney General or any other state or local authority to make public the identity of a person or insurer found to have violated this Act, the nature of the violation, or any related enforcement action, penalty, or settlement
b. Examples include: CA (Excluded Corporate Expenses in Ratemaking), LA (Mandatory Policyholder Notice)
2. (Consumer Intervenor Funding Mechanism) These model provisions allow independent consumer advocacy groups to formally challenge rate applications and recover actuarial and legal costs directly from the insurer if their intervention makes a substantial contribution to rejecting unjustified expenses.
a. Sample language:
i. Right of intervention. Any person or independent consumer advocacy group may initiate or intervene in any rate review proceeding or hearing before the [Department] to formally challenge a rate application or excluded expense statement and enforce the provisions of this Act. adapted from from Cal. Ins. Code § 1861.10(a)
ii. Recovery of actuarial and legal costs for substantial contribution.
1. The [Department] or a court shall award reasonable advocacy, actuarial, expert witness, and legal fees, and any other associated expenses to any independent consumer advocacy group or person who successfully brings an action under this subsection and:
a. Represents the interests of consumers and is financially independent of any insurer or insurance trade association; and
b. Makes a substantial contribution to the adoption of any order, regulation, or decision rejecting or reducing unjustified corporate expenses or excessive rates.
2. An order for actuarial, expert witness, and legal fees, and any other associated expenses awarded under this subsection shall be paid within thirty [30] days of the order.
b. Example: CA
Fair Markets
Effective Government
Effective Government